Jun 8, 2016 New Survey: Vast Majority of Pension-Fund Beneficiaries Oppose Fossil Fuel Divestment
First-of-its-kind survey asks and answers critical but previously unexplored question: What do actual pensioners think of divestment?
WASHINGTON, D.C. – Coming on the heels of news this week that the District of Columbia Retirement Board intends to divest its direct financial holdings in hydrocarbon-energy producers, while not selling any of its larger commingled funds that contain many of the same stocks, the Independent Petroleum Association of America (IPAA) today unveiled major new research findings that for the first time quantify the opinions of those who stand to lose the most under activist-led divestment campaigns: the pension beneficiaries themselves.
Completed last month, the survey captures the views of nearly 800 individuals from all across the United States who self-identified as beneficiaries of pension-fund disbursements, with all respondents deriving pension-related income from prior service in the public sector. As such, the sample is composed primarily of retired teachers, fire and police officers, and state, municipal and federal government personnel.
Asked the question directly of whether they could support divestment if doing so could lead to lower returns, nearly two out of three respondents said they could not. Asked to name an industry from which they might be comfortable divesting under certain circumstances, only nine percent of respondents identified firms or industries related to oil and gas. In Texas, 88 percent of respondents said they would actively oppose divesting from oil and gas companies, and large majorities registered the same position in Pennsylvania (77 percent), Ohio (71 percent) and New York (72 percent) as well, among other states.
“Arguably the strangest thing about the current debate over pension-fund divestment is that no one seems to know or particularly care what actual pension beneficiaries think about these policies,” said Jeff Eshelman, senior vice president of IPAA and director of the association’s DivestmentFacts.com campaign. “This new, first-of-its-kind survey helps us at least answer that basic question: pensioners, no matter where they live or how they vote, don’t like these divestment schemes one bit. What the findings show is that folks believe they’ve earned this money, that they’re entitled to receive it, and that they don’t want their financial well-being later in life to be impacted by activist-led political stunts. And who could blame them?”
As respondents during the course of the survey were presented with arguments both in support and opposed to divestment, opposition continued to mount throughout. Opposition levels reached a high of 75 percent after participants were presented with the argument that divesting from oil and natural gas firms makes no sense so long as society continues to rely on the products they produce as a key component of everyday life. Among the key demographics represented in this survey, a plurality of participants identified themselves as Democrats (38 percent), with a large majority indicating they were holders of at least a college degree (69 percent).
The release of these new survey results follows the issuance earlier this month of a new report by a professor at Arizona State Univ. quantifying the “frictional costs” of divestment – primarily transactional and compliance-related costs that all institutions that attempt to fully divestment would bear simply for executing the transaction. These costs, which the research showed could exceed $7.4 billion for a large portfolio over a 20-year period, would come in addition to any performance-related losses incurred as a result of having a less-diversified, hollowed-out portfolio thanks to divestment.
The survey also comes as divestment activists launch a new protest later today targeting the California State Teachers’ Retirement System. CalSTRS’s chief investment and executive officers have previously said that divestment is a bad idea, and one they could not support.
The final survey findings memo can be found here. The top-line questions and answers for the survey can be accessed here. The Arizona State report is available here. For more information and to access additional resources and collaterals, please visit DivestmentFacts.com.
About the Independent Petroleum Association of America
The Independent Petroleum Association of America (IPAA) is a national upstream trade association representing thousands of independent oil and natural gas producers and service companies across the United States. Independent producers develop 90 percent of the nation’s oil and natural gas wells. These companies account for 54 percent of America’s oil production, 85 percent of its natural gas production, and support over 2.1 million American jobs. Learn more about IPAA by visiting www.ipaa.org and following @IPAAaccess on Twitter.